Thursday, August 13, 2020

It is Nonsensical to Compare Covid-19 to Other Major Pandemics, Like the 1918 Pandemic

The 1918 Pandemic


By Sebastian Rushworth M.D.

Ok, I want to preface this article by stating that it is entirely anecdotal and based on my experience working as a doctor in the emergency room of one of the big hospitals in Stockholm, Sweden, and of living as a citizen in Sweden. As many people know, Sweden is perhaps the country that has taken the most relaxed attitude of any towards the covid pandemic. Unlike other countries, Sweden never went in to complete lockdown. Non-essential businesses have remained open, people have continued to go to caf├ęs and restaurants, children have remained in school, and very few people have bothered with face masks in public.

Covid hit Stockholm like a storm in mid-March. One day I was seeing people with appendicitis and kidney stones, the usual things you see in the emergency room. The next day all those patients were gone and the only thing coming in to the hospital was covid. Practically everyone who was tested had covid, regardless of what the presenting symtom was. People came in with a nose bleed and they had covid. They came in with stomach pain and they had covid.

Then, after a few months, all the covid patients disappeared. It is now four months since the start of the pandemic, and I haven’t seen a single covid patient in over a month. When I do test someone because they have a cough or a fever, the test invariably comes back negative. At the peak three months back, a hundred people were dying a day of covid in Sweden, a country with a population of ten million. We are now down to around five people dying per day in the whole country, and that number continues to drop. Since people generally die around three weeks after infection, that means virtually no-one is getting infected any more. If we assume around 0.5 percent of those infected die (which I think is very generous, more on that later), then that means that three weeks back 1,000 people were getting infected per day in the whole country, which works out to a daily risk per person of getting infected of 1 in 10,000, which is miniscule. And remember, the risk of dying is at the very most 1 in 200 if you actually do get infected. And that was three weeks ago. Basically, covid is in all practical senses over and done with in Sweden. After four months.

In total covid has killed under 6,000 people in a country of ten million. A country with an annual death rate of around 100,000 people. Considering that 70% of those who have died of covid are over 80 years old, quite a few of those 6,000 would have died this year anyway. That makes covid a mere blip in terms of its effect on mortality.

That is why it is nonsensical to compare covid to other major pandemics, like the 1918 pandemic that killed tens of millions of people. Covid will never even come close to those numbers. And yet many countries have shut down their entire economies, stopped children going to school, and made large portions of their population unemployed in order to deal with this disease.

The media have been proclaiming that only a small percentage of the population have antibodies, and therefore it is impossible that herd immunity has developed. Well, if herd immunity hasn’t developed, where are all the sick people? Why has the rate of infection dropped so precipitously? Considering that most people in Sweden are leading their lives normally now, not socially distancing, not wearing masks, there should still be high rates of infection.

The reason we test for antibodies is because it is easy and cheap. Antibodies are in fact not the body’s main defence against virus infections. T-cells are. But T-cells are harder to measure than antibodies, so we don’t really do it clinically. It is quite possible to have T-cells that are specific for covid and thereby make you immune to the disease, without having any antibodies. Personally, I think this is what has happened. Everybody who works in the emergency room where I work has had the antibody test. Very few actually have antibodies. This is in spite of being exposed to huge numbers of infected people, including at the beginning of the pandemic, before we realized how widespread covid was, when no-one was wearing protective equipment.

Read the rest here.

1 comment:

  1. If you go to the CDC website using these two links, you get the national hospitalization rates for Covid-19:

    https://gis.cdc.gov/grasp/COVIDNet/COVID19_3.html
    https://gis.cdc.gov/grasp/COVIDNet/COVID19_5.html

    The first link provides cumulative and weekly totals. The second link shows percentages of other present medical conditionsmat the time of admission. For the current week, the CDC shows a hospitalization rate at 4:100,000 ie 1:25,000 chance of going to the hospital WITH Covid-19.

    HOWEVER, the second link indicates that only 9% of those admitted to the hospital had no other detected underlying medical condition. That tells me maybe less than 10% of people admitted to the hospital who were otherwise healthy were admitted BECAUSE of Covid ie less than 1:100,000 healthy people go to the hospital because of Covid.

    Even the CDC accumulated total hospitalization rate (as of week 31) of 138:100,000 means that only 14:100,000 total healthy people have gone to the hospital for Covid since this plandemic started.

    And of those 14:100,000, maybe 1:100,000 actually died... likely killed by the hospital due to complications from intubation when put on a respirator.

    ReplyDelete